I’m pretty sure I didn’t even know chicken salad existed when I was growing up (now, TUNA salad I was familiar with…).
But when I moved to Atlanta and began having catered rep lunches, I fell in love with it. The best part is how many variations there are. There’s regular, Southern-style, with mustard, with curry, Waldorf, just about anything really.
We were in Texas visiting family four or five years ago, and my Aunt Tina (who has other amazing talents, like cake baking/decorating) made this chicken salad. It’s in the
(Blair) Waldorf family, and is the best chicken salad I have EVER had in my life. The combination of cider vinegar, honey, and white pepper in the dressing is the secret, I think.
It’s like crack. Sweet, tangy, mayo-covered crack.
My mom and I both begged the recipe off of her, and have made it a few times—including about 8 gallons of it (no, seriously) for my sister’s wedding reception dinner. It’s really easy, though kind of time consuming and makes quite a bit. Great for big groups, like picnics and family get-togethers. Handwritten—this is how you know it’s a good recipe.
You want a BIG bowl. We’re going to make a mess. Measure out the mayo. I love Duke’s (what good Southerner doesn’t?) but any mayo will do. We used light Miracle Whip for this one.
Add the poppy seeds. Throw in the honey and apple cider vinegar.
Then stir all the dressing ingredients together well.
Now halve the grapes and add them.
Chop up the celery—it’s best to make them very small pieces, and even. Usually most people don’t want to taste and feel LOTS of celery.
For the chicken, you can use pre-cooked chicken (like rotisserie) or just boil chicken breasts (what I do because I’m lazy). Cut or shred the chicken into small pieces and add to the big bowl. I’m not usually super exact on the amount of chicken, the recipe is a little flexible.
Toast the pecans. We used just plain pecans (no butter or sugar) in the oven at 400 for like five minutes. Chop or break them into pieces and toss into the bowl. Or you could go the lazy route and use pecan pieces to begin with…
Now mix everything all together. You might have to add a tiny more mayo if your salad is super dry, but don’t automatically assume that—if you let it sit a little while the celery and grapes tend to add a little moisture in themselves.
It’s awesome right away, but best if you let it sit in the refrigerator overnight or for a few hours at least. It gets chilled, but also the flavors all sink into and enhance each other. Like lasagna, but with mayo.
All done! It keeps for 3 days to a week in the fridge.
It’s good on pretty much everything—by itself, on crackers, croissants, bread, salad, etc. And with crunchy Cheetos.
Aunt Tina’s Best Chicken Salad In The World
- 8-9 cooked chicken breasts, shredded or cut into small pieces
- 1 cup of celery (chopped)
- 1 cup of red seedless grapes (sliced in half)
- 1 cup of toasted chopped pecans
- 2 1/2 cups of mayonnaise (I love Duke’s)
- 3 tablespoons of honey
- 2 1/2 tablespoons of apple cider vinegar
- 1/8 teaspoon of white pepper
- 3 tablespoons of poppy seeds
- Mix the dressing together.
- Add chicken and other ingredients, mix well.
- Best if kept in refrigerator overnight, it helps the flavors be even better!
Pin this image!
Just made this for our lunch. Yummy!! Made a few changes based on what I had and thought you’d like to see. Left out honey. Used craisins instead of grapes. Sunflower seeds instead of nuts. Didn’t measure anything cause it was annoying to keep checking on my phone so I went for texture. And I used home canned chicken (2 jars)!!! It was my first time canning too so that is pretty darn exciting! :). Came out fantastic! Will make again. PS we ate ours on pita bread.
So glad you liked it! For me the honey balances out the bite of the apple cider vinegar, but I have a fairly low threshold for vinegar-y things in general. Craisins would be good, and less work than cutting a bunch of grapes in half. Really happy to hear that about the canned chicken–I’ve been wanting to try chicken salad with canned chicken for a while but it also kind of freaks me out and so I’ve “chickened” out so far 🙂