Dessert Recipes & Other Sweet Treats

It’s no secret that I love sweets. But not just any sweets…really good homemade ones, none of that store-bought nonsense for me. So I have a huge arsenal of the best dessert recipes across a wide spectrum—from more traditional cakes, pies, puddings, and cookies, to slightly more exotic babkas, biscotti, pavlovas, and choux.

I’ve got some great family secret recipes (like my mom’s amazing molasses cookies), a bunch of great gluten-free desserts if you need them, and desserts that are perfect for holiday gatherings.

Not sure where to start?? Here are a few of my faves:

You can browse my full recipe index or a more visual index here, or explore the archives below…

Paul Hollywood’s Chelsea Buns

June 17, 2020

It’s hard to tell you how magical these chelsea buns are. Fragrant spices, tart and chewy fruit with a whiff of bourbon, citrus tang. Soft, pillowy dough. Sweet icing. It was truly revelatory.

I’ve wanted to try these out, and decided that Paul Hollywood’s recipe had to be where I start…I only know about them from the Great British Bake-Off, so feels fitting.

What is a chelsea bun?? Chelsea buns aren’t really a thing in the U.S…at least as far as I’m aware. I’d certainly never heard of them before I started watching the Great British Bake-Off.

They are a currant sweet bun from the 1700s, once favored by royalty. Made basically the same way as a cinnamon roll, but stuffed with dried fruit instead and usually with some citrus zest in there. They’re a real British staple.

(Side note, I just went down a rabbit hole about the difference between currants, raisins, and sultanas, soooo…)

And I’m so glad I’ve tried them out, because they were so worth it!

If you’re looking at the ingredients list and thinking “whoa, that’s intense!”…don’t be put off by it. It’s not nearly as complicated or intense as it looks, I promise. I just like to write detailed instructions because I think it makes life easier…and I have step-by-step photos throughout the post so you can see how everything should look.

READ THE POST

10-Minute Stovetop Pink Grapefruit Curd

June 4, 2020

Anyone who knows me well will tell you that I am a lover of all things grapefruit. Citrus things in general are up my alley, but there’s something special about a ruby red or pink grapefruit flavor. So after I first tried my hand at a lemon curd and was blown away by its ease and flavor, I knew that a pink grapefruit curd was in my future.

The bright, sweet, soft flavors of this curd are inextricably associated with early spring for me.

As I fiddled with getting this recipe just right, we got a stretch of cool but sunny days, pink flowers popping out on the trees, and the neighborhood lawns turning a rich green. It’s a happy flavor tied to a happy time.

This pink grapefruit curd is a super simple adaptation of this simple lemon curd recipe. The technique is exactly the same, but I had to tweak the ingredient amounts slightly for both this and my blood orange version.

Because the grapefruit and the blood orange are softer, sweeter citrus flavors vs. the intensity and tartness of lemon, you need to back off slightly on both the sugar and butter in order for the real flavor of the fruit to shine through. It pairs really well with strawberries, raspberries, and the like.

Naturally this curd will be yellow, because the pink juice can’t win out against the egg’s yolk. If you want it to be pink, just add a TINY drop of food coloring (I prefer this gel coloring set and use it all the time). READ THE POST

Dark Chocolate Bundt Cake With Peanut Butter Glaze

May 10, 2020

One day I had a day dream. I dreamed of a dark, moist, bittersweet chocolate bundt cake paired with an intensely peanut butter glaze. Like SUPER peanut butter-y, that kind of sweet/salty combo that’s amazing.

Problem was, finding a glaze that matched my vision was way harder than I thought it would be. Finally after quite a bit of digging, this came onto my radar, and with a few tweaks it was absolutely perfect.

This was one of the first things I baked after the “shelter in place” orders started, and I quickly realized how dangerous my stress baking habit was going to be. Thankfully I dug up the willpower to take two pieces for myself and gift the rest to a co-worker…with a 6-foot distance 🙂

I often find bundt cakes dense and dry, but this cake is the complete opposite…rich but light, super moist, almost fluffy. The glaze is a little sticky, but keeping it from getting too sweet helps the textures and flavors balance out. And the chocolate and peanut butter combo can’t be beat.

I love how easy this cake is to whip up as well! Other than just mixing up the chocolate portion ahead of time, this cake batter comes together in just a few minutes, then is in the oven with very little hands-on effort.READ THE POST

10-Minute Stovetop Lemon Curd

April 15, 2020

The real question for this week is, why have I not made lemon curd before?!

I feel like you all are terrible friends for not making me try this earlier. Because, GUYS, this lemon curd is so easy and so delicious, and takes less than 10 minutes. You can do it while you’re waiting for your coffee to brew, or…other things that take around 10 minutes? I don’t know at this point. Regardless, it’s fast.

This lemon curd is quite sharp, but light and creamy. It’s perfect as a filling in simple crepes, topping a pavlova, or swirled through yogurt. Go nuts…layer it between cakes, spread it on toast, top coconut milk ice cream with it.

You might also like this pink grapefruit curd and blood orange curd!

In doing some research, I picked up a couple tips that were helpful (and mentioned in the recipe card below). First, don’t use aluminum cookware because it reacts with the lemon juice. I used a small stainless steel saucepan, which works perfectly. It’s important not to use too much heat…a good medium flame should work.

And then I recommend stirring together the sugar with the egg, and then add the juice right as you’re putting on the heat. If you add the juice to eggs without the sugar, the acid in the juice will “cook” the eggs and you’ll get those little white bits.

READ THE POST

Dark Chocolate & Whiskey “Irish Coffee” Cake

March 15, 2020

This is a story of what happens when someone makes a casual suggestion and I go down the rabbit hole. And end up with a delicious, dark, complex cake modeled off an Irish Coffee cocktail.

It started with a co-worker asking if I could make a Guinness chocolate cake but with Irish Whiskey instead. Intrigued, I dug into various stout and whiskey cake recipes to get a sense of proportions, textures, flavors, and more.

I wanted to make sure the complex flavors of the whiskey came out—my sister insists that anything made with alcohol *taste* like it—but not ruin either texture or flavor of the cake. I tried two different cakes and two different glazes before settling on this.

Between them, there was a clear winner on glaze, but I waffled on the cake. I ended up going with the one that’s a more traditional bundt cake texture (a bit denser and richer), but I did love the other one (lighter, so fell apart easier).

I had trouble figuring out what to call this cake. Specifically, I was translating Slane’s take on the iconic Irish Coffee cocktail, which meant ensuring that hints of vanilla and orange come through without overpowering the coffee and whiskey taste. I also wanted to make sure that the chocolate flavor didn’t completely take over. But it’s not a “coffee cake” like most people think…

I also chose a beautiful decorative bundt cake because I can’t decorate cakes to save my life! I can make delicious cakes but if I try to frost and decorate them, it looks like a 5-year-old did it. So I’ve been playing around with gorgeous bundt molds for built-in aesthetics 🙂

I thought Slane was amazing in this cake, because it’s such a rich, complex whiskey. I’ve found most Irish whiskies to be much lighter and one-note than I’m into, and I’d recommend using one with a bit more flavor. Whether it’s Slane, something like Jameson Caskmates, or even a good bourbon…something that brings flavor other than just “alcohol”.

So let’s do this, shall we???READ THE POST

The Most Amazing, Moist Lemon-Orange Pound Cake

March 7, 2020

We’ve reached that point in the late-winter-almost-spring-dear-goodness-let-it-be-spring where I desperately need warmth and sunshine. And this lemon orange pound cake is basically the pastry embodiment of sunshine, so it will just have to do.

I’ve adapted this recipe from a lemon pound cake that A Beautiful Plate posted. While I love lemon with my whole heart, I thought that the addition of orange would bring a balance with a milder and sweeter citrus. And boy, does it ever! I also upped the citrus in the glaze in particular.

Besides the amazing flavor, the other thing to love about this cake is the texture—it’s so moist! In my experience, pound cakes are denser and drier, but the greek yogurt helps keep this super soft and fluffy. Basically, this cake is a winner!

(On a side note, I absolutely love the stunning Magnolia bundt cake pan I made this in…was my first time trying it out!).

READ THE POST

Apple Butter Cinnamon-Sugar Babka

February 2, 2020

This is one of those places where I cram a lot of my favorite things into one recipe and see how it comes out. Apple butter, check. Cinnamon-sugar, check. Soft delicious challah dough in a twisty babka bread?? Check.

And I’ll be honest…halfway through making this I was pretty sure it was going to be a disaster.

I can’t remember what gave me this particular brainwave, but it was very likely when I made a new batch of my amazing homemade apple butter and was thinking of all the different ways it could be used.

I’d been browsing challah and babka recipes including peanut butter and jelly, tahini and pistachio, and so many more, and thought…why not apple butter??

So I started looking for apple butter babka recipes and really kind of came up empty. Which I found surprising, because it feels like such a logical and beloved flavor combo. So after finding a few different things that were in the right direction, I set out to figure out something on my own.

I think you’re going to like it…

READ THE POST

Raspberry Skyr Cake With White & Dark Chocolate

December 26, 2019

When I went to Iceland last year, I was delayed for 24 hours and so my friend V had a whole day on her own to explore. When I picked her up in the rental car, she greeted me with coffee and pastries (smart girl!) and the first thing she said was “Wow, Iceland men are like real MEN!” The second thing she said was “Also, the milk here is so good!” True story on both counts.

She was seriously obsessed with all their dairy products (and apparently there’s a scientific reason), and we drank and ate a ton of it while in the country. Skyr is one of the most well-known of their dairy products, a lot like Greek yogurt (though interesting, produced more like cheese).

You’ll find skyr cake in Iceland but it will be more like a no-bake cheesecake. And DELICIOUS. But I didn’t want to deal with the hassle of gelatin sheets and all, so I decided to make a slightly different kind of cake with skyr…using it the way you’d use sour cream or yogurt to give some tang and moisture.

(Side note, if you’d like to see some of the AH-MAZING things we saw and did in Iceland, I’ve got you covered!)

This skyr cake is packed full of raspberries and both white and dark chocolate chips, and is even better than I thought it would be. The white chocolate isn’t really present as a flavor, but kind of melts into cake to provide extra moistness and texture. I sliced myself off a few pieces and then called my sister to come take it away from me and have her family eat it!

READ THE POST

Bing Cherry Pie With Streusel Topping

December 7, 2019

I love pie. Pie is the best. But for a holiday where pie plays a major role, I don’t really love Thanksgiving pies. Thanksgiving’s a big deal in my family. We always come home. We get together not only all day on Thanksgiving, but pretty much every other day that weekend. We play football. We play cards. There are glorious sunsets. There is SO much food. This year I think we actually set a record.

[Note: I edited and republished this in December 2019 with refreshed photos]

Every year I make a fruit pie or two, because pumpkin, German chocolate, and chocolate chip pie are just not for me. There’s usually a pear-apple pie with streusel topping, or some similar combination (I’ve been on a roll with this bourbon pear crumble pie). A couple years ago, though, I was really at a loss for what else to make, and then my mom found a bag of dark cherries in the freezer.

After looking up a number of recipes on Pinterest, I had to basically make up the recipe and hope it would work (I had visions of it just being this giant pool of juice, the soggiest pie ever). It was actually super simple and so easy to throw together.

This bing cherry pie ended up being my favorite dessert that year, and I had it for lunch, dinner, breakfast the next morning, and the tiny sliver that was left the next morning as well. This pie is my everything. I have no idea why, but it’s amazing.

READ THE POST

Pear-Apple Pie With Streusel Topping

November 27, 2019

I’ve been on a kick of re-making some of my all-time favorite recipes, many of which I’ve (inexplicably) never posted on this site. Completely on a whim this week, I whipped up this pear-apple pie (and proceeded to entirely eat it myself over the course of a few days…) and fell in love with it all over again. I made up this recipe several years ago and it definitely holds up over time.

I think streusel topping is totally underrated as a pie topping. I’m a sucker for the crumbly-crunchy-spiced-sweet texture and flavor it adds, and it’s so much easier than putting a pie crust topper on. I have a basic streusel formula I use and adapt as needed for different recipes, and it couldn’t be simpler.

I almost always make this for Thanksgiving when I go home to visit my family (and we eat on it for several days), so I have a strong association with the flavors here and fall in Kansas. In particular, the beautiful (and chilly) sunsets, quiet runs on our dirt road, and a breakfast of pie and coffee the next morning.

I also love that this recipe is reasonably healthy (as desserts go) and super easy to make. Other than dealing with pie crust dough (something I’m not terribly skilled with), the filling and topping are crazy simple and don’t require any special skills. You can throw this together while making dinner or doing other things, and it’s pretty forgiving if you don’t do something exactly right. In fact there isn’t really an “exactly right” with this recipe. You do you.